The same winged liner can look sharp on one face and vanish into the lid fold on another. The reason is eye shape. The shape of your eye decides where a line shows when your eyes are open, how thick it needs to be, and which way the wing should point.
Eyeliner was everywhere on Singapore’s office commute when this guide first appeared, with K-beauty a big reason why. The basic idea hasn’t changed: before you buy a pencil, gel or liquid liner, work out which eye shape you have.
Start by reading your eye shape
Stand in front of a mirror with your face relaxed, eyebrows down, and look straight ahead. This is the view other people see, so it is the shape your liner has to work with.
Almond eyes are slightly pointed at the outer ends and have a visible crease. Round eyes look large and circular, with white visible around the iris. Monolid eyes have little or no visible crease, and the upper lid is smooth and flat.
Hooded eyes have skin from the brow bone folding over the lid, which hides the crease. That fold is why eyeliner on hooded eyes can disappear or smudge onto the upper lid once the eye opens.
Formula matters more for some shapes than others. Gel liners and waterproof pencils hold up better than standard pencils and liquids on hooded and monolid eyes, because the lid skin touches the line all day.
How to apply it, shape by shape
Almond eyes
Almond eyes suit almost any style, but a classic cat eye is a natural fit. Draw a thin line along the inner two-thirds of the upper lash line, then thicken it along the outer third. Take the wing outward along the angle of the lower lash line rather than flicking it sharply upward. If you want more drama, line the lower lashes too.
Hooded eyes
Draw with your eyes open, looking straight ahead, so you can see where the hood falls. For a wing, sketch its shape in this position, angling it towards the tail of your brow at roughly 30 to 45 degrees. It should sit above the fold, not on it. Then close your eye and fill the gap between the wing and the lash line. Tightlining, which means filling in the waterline between the lashes with a waterproof gel or pencil, adds definition without using the lid space the hood covers.
Monolid eyes
A thin line along the lashes often can’t be seen on a monolid once the eye is open, so go slightly thicker. One method starts the line at the inner corner and builds it up as it extends past the outer corner. Another is to soften it into a smoked-out, diffused wing instead of a hard graphic line. Bold lines, wings and tightlining all work on this shape. For an almond-like tapered monolid, draw the line out past the outer corner first, then add the wing.
Round and downturned eyes
Round eyes can take a line extended outward, which makes them look more almond-shaped. Downturned eyes look best with a short, subtle flick that angles gently upward to lift the outer corner.
Common mistakes to avoid
Judging the line only with your eyes closed is the most common mistake, especially on hooded eyes. Open and close your eyes a few times to check for smudging onto the lid or uneven edges. Check both eyes in the mirror before you adjust anything.
Shade is another trap. Black gives the most definition on monolid and deep-set eyes. On hooded eyes, stick to black or dark brown, because lighter shades get lost under the fold.
Finally, press the liner right into the lash line rather than painting it on top of the lid. This keeps product off the rest of the eyelid.