There are two kinds of combination skin. Both have an oily T-zone (the forehead, nose and chin). What separates them is everything else. With oily-combination skin, the rest of the face feels fairly balanced. With dry-combination skin, the cheeks are dry and can flake, and sometimes the jawline is too.
This matters when choosing a foundation. A formula made to control shine can catch on dry cheeks, and a rich one can slide off the nose by lunchtime. For a dry-combination skin type, the aim is a base that moisturises the dry areas without clogging pores or stripping the skin.
Why one face needs two approaches
Dry-combination skin is easiest to handle by zones: hydrate the dry areas and keep the T-zone in check. Hyaluronic acid is a humectant, so it draws water into the skin and helps keep dry cheeks plump and smooth. Niacinamide (vitamin B3) supports the skin barrier and helps even out the look of oil, so it works on both zones.
Finish counts as much as formula. Liquid or cream foundations with a satin, natural or semi-matte finish give dry areas enough moisture without adding shine to oily ones. A heavy matte or very dewy finish usually works on only one half of the face.
How to choose and apply it
In October 2015, the advice for dry-combination skin was to choose moisturising textures: tinted moisturisers, liquids and creams. The picks that season were Nars Pure Radiant Tinted Moisturizer (seven shades, S$66), Shu Uemura The Lightbulb Fluid Foundation (10 shades, S$75), La Mer The Treatment Foundation (five shades, S$160), Laneige BB Cushion Anti-aging SPF50+ PA+++ (seven shades, S$62) and SK-II Stempower Cream Compact Foundation (one shade, S$101 for the refill and S$34 for the case).
Many current formulas are designed with combination skin in mind. Shiseido’s Synchro Skin Self-Refreshing Foundation SPF 30 is oil-free and fragrance-free, and contains antioxidants. Pat McGrath Labs’ Skin Fetish: Sublime Perfection Foundation is also oil-free and fragrance-free, with a natural matte finish. Armani’s Luminous Silk Foundation is lightweight, moisturising and oil-free.
Some foundations name the skin type on the bottle: Clinique sells Superbalanced Makeup for dry-combination to combination-oily skin. If cushions are your format, Hourglass makes the Ambient Soft Glow Foundation in a cushion. Serum-foundation hybrids are a newer category of light, skincare-style formulas that also suit combination skin.
Prep makes a difference too. A non-comedogenic moisturiser for combination skin, applied mostly where the skin needs it, helps foundation last longer. Apply with a damp sponge rather than a brush. Bouncing the sponge presses foundation onto dry cheeks and blends it out thinly, so dry patches stand out less.
Common mistakes
Using powder foundation all over. In 2015, the advice was to skip compact powder foundation, just as you would with dry skin. It could look good on the T-zone but made the rest of the face look cakey. Powder still works well on an oily T-zone, but it tends to look dry and heavy on the cheeks.
Treating the shine with more foundation. In 2015, makeup artist Larry Yeo suggested blotting oil from the T-zone with a tissue and then dusting loose powder only there. The same zonal approach applies today: a light layer of powder through the T-zone, not all over, and blotting papers for touch-ups in the afternoon instead of more powder.
Ignoring the dry areas. If foundation catches on flaky cheeks, the cause is often dehydration rather than the shade or the formula. Ceramides, fatty lipids, aloe, shea butter and botanical oils are all moisturising ingredients that can sit under or inside a foundation for dry patches. Oil-free formulas are better near the nose and forehead.