Cheap and good liquid eyeliners that don’t smudge on oily eyelids

Which eyeliner won’t smudge on oily lids? When this guide first ran in August 2016, the answer was a set of ten budget liquid liners. They were tested on oily eyelids without eye primer, and primer was suggested as an optional step for longer wear. The test is the same today: a liner has to set into a film that sebum and humidity can’t break down by midday.

The picks below are liquid liners with sweat-, tear- or sebum-resistant formulas. Prices are given with the year they were recorded, because shelf prices change. Here they are.

Liquid eyeliners for oily lids on Singapore shelves

Heroine Make Smooth Liquid Eyeliner (S$19.50 in 2024). The Japanese liner had a reformulated “super keep” version containing a polymer. It dries to a film that resists tears, sweat, water and sebum. The 0.1mm tip makes fine lines and wings easier to draw.

SilkyGirl Precision Liquid Eyeliner (S$12.90 in 2024). This waterproof, pigmented liner was the cheapest Singapore pick that year. A waterproof formula means fewer touch-ups through a humid day.

NYX Professional Makeup Matte Liquid Liner in Black (S$14 in 2024). It dries to a matte finish and sets without transferring or smudging, even though the colour is very black. The applicator takes a little more practice than a felt pen.

Browlash Ex Liquid Eyeliner in Deep Black (S$19.90 in 2024). Its felt tip is soft but firm enough for beginners to control. The intensely black formula resists smudging and sebum, and held up even when applied along the lower lashes.

Budget picks from international tests

NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner (about US$10). Yahoo’s shopping team named it the best waterproof, smudge-proof liquid liner after testing more than 40 eyeliners. They noted it was easy to control and certified cruelty-free. Some reviewers found it occasionally bled or feathered.

Milani Stay Put Eyeliner. In TODAY’s roundup of smudge-proof liners recommended by makeup artists, this was the affordable pick. It comes in three colours, and Milani says it lasts up to 16 hours.

Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen No-Skip Eyeliner. This felt-tip pen is a pharmacy staple. Maybelline markets it as cry-proof, which helps on lids that water as well as shine.

Rare Beauty Perfect Strokes Matte Liquid Liner (US$21 at Sephora). It cost more than the others here, and Yahoo named it the best liquid eyeliner overall in the same test.

Liner Tip Price recorded
Heroine Make Smooth Liquid Eyeliner Brush, 0.1mm S$19.50 (2024)
SilkyGirl Precision Liquid Eyeliner Liquid S$12.90 (2024)
Browlash Ex Liquid Eyeliner Felt S$19.90 (2024)
NYX Epic Ink Liner Felt About US$10

Getting liquid liner to last on oily lids

Waterproof and film-forming formulas hold up best on oily lids, because the dried layer sits on top of the skin’s oil instead of mixing with it. Pencil liners can be more of a gamble. Yahoo’s testers reported that some users with oily skin found About-Face Line Artist, its top pencil, smudged.

Eye primer remains an optional extra step. The liners in the 2016 test were judged without it, and primer was suggested as a way to make any of them last longer.

FAQ

– Is a felt-tip or brush-tip liquid eyeliner better for oily eyelids?

Both can work if the formula is waterproof or sebum-resistant. Felt tips like the Browlash Ex and NYX Epic Ink give beginners more control, while a fine brush like Heroine Make’s 0.1mm tip draws sharper wings.

– Do I need eye primer if my eyeliner is waterproof?

Not necessarily. The liners in the original 2016 test stayed put on oily lids without primer, but adding primer can make wear last longer.