The 4 best eye primers for eyeshadow that stays put

A thin layer of eyelid primer takes about ten seconds and changes how eyeshadow wears over a long, humid day. Primer goes on bare lids before colour. It stops shadow gathering in the crease, keeps eyeliner from smudging into trails and makes pigments look brighter for longer. That matters most with metallics and glitter.

Primer also evens out lids that look red or patchy, so the colour you put on top looks the same as it did in the pan. Here are four primers on sale in 2026 and what sets each one apart.

Too Faced Shadow Insurance

This primer has been around for years under the name Shadow Insurance Anti-Crease Eye Shadow Primer. It is now sold as Shadow Insurance 24-Hour Eyeshadow Primer, in a 6ml tube with a doe-foot applicator. The formula is featherweight and translucent, and Too Faced says it works under both cream and powder shadows for 24 hours of wear without creasing or fading. Too Faced also says it helps intensify eyeshadow color and control oil while remaining suitable across skin tones.

The key ingredients include isododecane, silica, licorice and marshmallow root, and it dries to a natural finish without colour correction. Who What Wear UK picked it as the Best Lightweight Formula at £21. It praised the smooth, creamy texture but found the packaging a little more bulky.

The formula is concentrated, so a tiny amount covers both lids. Give it about 30 seconds to settle before you add colour. Primers like this one put a barrier between the skin’s natural oils and the shadow, which is what stops shadow slipping.

NARS Pro-Prime Smudge Proof Eyeshadow Base

Who What Wear UK named the Nars Pro Prime Smudge Proof Eyeshadow Base, £26 its best overall eyeshadow primer after testing. It suits anyone whose eyeliner and shadow tend to drift by the afternoon. Press a little onto the lid with a fingertip, from the lash line up to the brow bone, and let it set before you blend shadow over it.

Urban Decay Eyeshadow Primer Potion

Urban Decay’s Primer Potion took the Best for Creasing spot in the same Who What Wear UK test, at £24. Its main job is to stop colour settling into the fold of the lid, which is where shadow tends to break up first on hooded eyes. Urban Decay also makes an Anti-Aging version of the Primer Potion.

Milk Makeup Hydro Grip Eye Primer

For dry lids, Who What Wear UK chose the Milk Makeup Hydro Grip Eye Primer, £23 as its best hydrating formula. A hydrating base is the gentler option when matte primers feel tight or look flaky on the lid.

How to apply eye primer

  • Start with clean, dry lids that have no moisturiser on them, so the primer can grip.
  • Use about a rice-grain amount per eye and tap it across the lid with your ring finger.
  • Wait around 30 seconds before applying shadow, especially bright or shimmery shades.
  • For glitter and metallics, build colour in thin layers over the primed lid instead of one heavy layer.
  • If you wear contact lenses, a primed lid helps hold loose shadow particles in place so fewer fall into the eye.

Some formulas work under concealer as well as on the lid. A thin layer under the eyes before concealer gives concealer more staying power. On lids, a clear primer like Shadow Insurance lets each shadow shade show true to colour, while tinted bases also even out discolouration.