5 eyeshadow mistakes you’re probably making, and how to fix them

Why eyeshadow goes wrong

Patchy colour, harsh edges and specks of fallout on the cheeks rarely come from just one problem. Most often a few small things go wrong at once: the wrong tool, a powder that is too hard or too loose, lids that weren’t prepped properly, too much product on the brush, and a finish that shows texture. Each one can make or break an eye look.

The tool controls how the powder spreads. A soft, fluffy blending brush moves over the crease and diffuses the edges between shades. The small sponge-tip applicator packed with many palettes tends to press colour on in patches, so blending takes longer. The texture of the skin underneath matters as well. Powder grabs onto dry or flaky spots and settles into creases, and light-reflecting pigments pick out every fine line.

How to get it right

Start with clean, smooth lids. A primer on its own is not enough as a base. Clean the eye area first with micellar water, then apply an eye cream. Let the cream absorb fully before the primer goes on. This order helps cut down on crepey texture, makes blending more even and reduces fallout. La Roche-Posay’s micellar solution for sensitive skin and Clinique’s All About Eyes Rich were the pairing suggested for this step.

Use a proper blending brush. Replace the sponge tip with a soft, fluffy brush. It can cut blending time roughly in half, because the bristles feather the colour out instead of leaving stripes. A multi-brush set, such as the Zoeva Classic Eye Set that was recommended, covers the jobs of laying down colour, blending and detailing in one buy.

Build colour slowly. Pick up a little product, tap the brush to knock off the excess, and add layers until the colour is as deep as you want. Starting with less gives softer edges and less fallout under the eyes.

Common mistakes to avoid

Judging a palette by its price. A high price does not guarantee a good formula. Some shadows are too hard to pick up, some are too powdery and drop everywhere, and some are under- or over-pigmented. Look for a smooth, almost creamy texture with rich colour payoff. For neutrals, the Kat Von D Shade + Light Eye Contour Palette was a suggested starting point. Bustle reported that the original version held 12 matte eyeshadows and that a Glimmer version was later added alongside it rather than replacing it.

Loading the brush. Too much product leaves harsh lines and uneven patches that take longer to blend out. It also adds to fallout. Tapping the brush before each layer is the quickest way to prevent this.

Reaching for shimmer on textured lids. Frosted, metallic and glitter shadows draw attention to fine lines and crepey skin, because their pigments reflect light. Matte or satin finishes are more flattering on mature eyes. The Tarte Tartelette Amazonian Clay Palette, an all-matte mix of neutrals and blush tones, was given as one option.

Treating primer as the whole prep. When primer goes on over unwashed or dry lids, the problems it should prevent come back: uneven blending, creasing and fallout. Cleansing first and letting the eye cream absorb before the primer goes on fixes both texture and how long the shadow lasts.